A 19th century sketch map of the Dutch colonial settlement of New Haarlem shows a number of interesting features.
Notice how the streets are oriented to true north/south, not on a ‘Manhattan-esque’ angle as they are now (based on The Commissioner’s Plan). Also, New Haarlem was centered around 122 and 2nd Avenue, not west along 125th Street. The Dutch village ultimately used the Harlem and East Rivers for most travel to/from other settlements.
As you can see below, there was a pond, centered on 125th street, between 2nd and 3rd Avenues:
And a road, leaving for Spuyten Duyvel (Inwood) headed due north from the church farm land which was on the outskirts of the village:
Lastly, the churchyard and graveyard were around 125/126 and 1st Avenue, where we now know there is a burial ground of enslaved Africans:
If you’ve walked north on Madison from 125th Street you might have seen the faded ad on the side of an east-side building:
Looking carefully, you’ll see it’s an ad for shoe polish. The brand of which I can’t make out: